The Leipzig State Court will soon make a ruling on a large corruption case. The prosecution accuses the US computer company Hewlett-Packard of paying at least 7.6 million Euros in bribes to Russian officials to secure a dominant position in the Russian market. But in reality, the documents reveal a much greater scandal. It was Vladimir Putin who enabled this corruption scandal. The bribe money from HP ensured Putin the loyalty of a clique of state attorneys. And helped him take control of the Russian judiciary.
In November 1999, Vladimir Putin initiates the purchase of a computer network for the Russian Prosecutor General’s Office. US computer maker Hewlett-Packard, wins the deal although it does not offer the lowest bid. HP shows its gratitude and pays at least 7.6 million Euros in bribe money.
The money ends up with Russian officials, including prosecutors and intelligence officials. Since then, no Russian general prosecutor has investigated Putin.
The deal would not have been possible without German help: the HP transaction is covered by a Hermes export guarantee.
Even big stories sometimes begin unspectacularly. This one starts in 2007, in the small town of Delitzsch in the East German State of Saxony, where tax officials investigate a computer dealer, Ralf K., a member of the Christian Democratic Party and a representative in the Northern Saxony district assembly.
Before long, the officials come across suspicious dealings relating to 21 million Euros that had been written off, but do not fit into the small business’s regular dealings. The computer salesman signed contracts worth millions of Euros in Russia although his company has neither the staff nor the means for such deals.
Something is wrong. The public prosecutor’s office is called in, along with INES, the „Saxony Integrated Investigation Unit“ which is specialized in complex corruption cases. The police rummage through piles of documents, finding ever more connections, accounts and questions. As if they were peeling an onion. Before long, the suspected tax evasion of a small business owner in Delitzsch turns into a corruption case that leads to the top of the Russian state.
The source of the money is soon uncovered: the American computer giant Hewlett-Packard (HP). Prosecutors allege that Ralf K. established a slush fund in early 2004 in cooperation with HP. First, a German subsidiary of Hewlett-Packard delivered computers and software for around 11 million Euros to Ralf K. And then Ralf K., according to state investigators, sold the same goods back to HP for around 21 million Euros. The profit, after provisions and expenses was around 9.3 million Euros.
Prosecutors allege this is dirty money that Ralf K. later transfered to accounts around the world.
But Ralf K. is only a small helper, one cog in a larger game. He does not receive orders from HP, but from the Russian Sergej B, according to state prosecutors. He met Ralf K. in the early 1990s when Sergej B. did an internship in Saxony. After that, the Russian and the German established companies with almost identical names and did business together across the former Soviet empire.
The investigators can also identify some of the recipients of the dirty money – primarily employees of the Russian intelligence service and the Prosecutor General’s Office of the Russian Federation.
The suspects also include Russian officials who did not receive direct payments, such as a Deputy Prosecutor General. Yuri Biryukov is a small man as hard as steel with an unpleasant rasping voice, who, on behalf of the Prosecutors General’s Office, signs fraudulent documents that set the bribery in motion.
Biryukov is a very important figure in Putin’s power structure. One example: in 2003, when the oil company Yukos is broken up and its boss, the oligarch Mikail Chodorkovsky, is sent to a prison camp, the person who signs the arrest warrant is the same Yuri Biryukov.
Investigators say, beginning in 2004 the bribes negotiated by Biryukov go via front companies to employees of the Prosecutor General’s Office and the intelligence service, FSB.
If an indictment filed by prosecutors against three former HP employees and Ralf K. leads to a conviction, then sentence could include stiff fines and the confiscation of millions of euros in profits. Is it merely another corruption scandal in a quintessentially corrupt country? Or is there more behind all this?
Yes, there is more.
How Putin takes power
We discover the real significance of the case when we go back to the year 1999. It is a fateful year for Russia. In this year, Putin stages a sex scandal, incites a war, breaks the independence of the Russian judiciary, rises to the Russian presidency – and enables bribery dealings with HP.
At the beginning of the year 1999, Russia is still a state governed by something resembling the rule of law, despite corruption and arbitrary power. A separation of powers is in place; independent representatives raise their voices in the parliament, the Duma, and parts of the judiciary work independently. The president’s name is Boris Yeltsin. But he faces difficulties. The Prosecutor General of the Russian Federation is investigating Yeltsin and his relatives. Undeclared assets belonging to the Yeltsin family have turned up in Switzerland. There Swiss prosecutors say the funds were used to purchase luxury goods. Meanwhile in Russia, the Prosecutor General, Yuri Skuratov, pursues a similar investigation.
Boris Yeltsin is in big trouble. But the president receives help from Vladimir Putin. A year earlier, when the investigation had only just begun, Yeltsin made Putin head of the domestic intelligence service FSB, the successor to the KGB.
The pressure on Prosecutor General Skuratov is immense. But he continues the investigation. Until 18th March 1999. On that day Russian television broadcasts a film showing a man resembling the Prosecutor General in bed with two women.
Looking at the grainy black-and-white video today, the suspicion immediately arises that it is a blatant fabrication. The participants behave as in a pornographic film, taking the camera position into careful account. And Prosecutor General Skuratov swears he is not the man in the film.
But the denial does not help. FSB chief Putin says in a televised interview: his experts have determined that the naked man in the sex tape is Prosecutor General Skuratov. The word of Putin, head of the spy service, is stronger – the same Putin who, when he was a an officer for the KGB in Dresden, wanted to blackmail a professor with pornographic material to get access to research results.
CORRECTIV asked the Russian president to comment on these allegations, but we have not received a reply.
With that, the Prosecutor General is finished, and soon he is put on leave. His successor is already in place: Vladimir Ustinov, along with his deputy, Yuri Biryukov, the small tough man with an unpleasant rasping voice. The two men know each other from the northern Caucasus, from the chaotic years after the First Chechen War.
The investigation of Boris Yeltsin is subsequently put on ice. And the president’s gratitude is shown: on 9th August 1999, Yeltsin appoints Putin as Prime Minister, the second man in power.
Putin’s tenure in office begins with terror. Every week for a month apartment buildings are bombed, almost 300 people die. On 22nd September, residents observe a number of men carrying sacks into the basement of an apartment building in the town of Rjasan. The police come and confiscate the sacks – which a bomb expert identifies as explosives. The men, it turns out, are agents of the spy service FSB.
But several days later the head of the intelligence service says the sacks were filled with sugar, and that the operation in Rjasan was an exercise to test local vigilance.
The Russian public still sees the apartment building terror as the work of Chechen terrorists. The Russian army had lost the first war against Chechnya; then it withdrew in 1996. According to one of his friends, Putin saw this defeat as a disgrace he wants to correct. Now he has a pretext. On 1st October 1999, Russian troops march into Chechnya. A few months later the new Prosecutor General closes his investigation into the purpose of the ominous sugar sacks.
The judiciary is now in Putin’s hands. It will no longer give him trouble.
Between all these events, a different decision has gone without notice. On 14th November 1999, Putin decides to do something nice for the Prosecutor General’s Office. In a government decree, he allows the authorities to borrow 30 million Dollars from a foreign bank to buy a new computer network.
A strange decision. Russia is almost bankrupt after the Ruble crisis. Hospitals are falling apart. Why take on foreign debt in a time of financial crisis for sake the Prosecutor General’s Office? Such deals invite corruption. Putin also knows this. Does he deliberately approve it so that the new Prosecutor General officials can fill their pockets, and so he can secure their loyalty?
Corruption with a German blessing
The contract is put up for bids. Hewlett-Packard is one of the companies to make an offer – and receives the contract in February 2001. The deal is supposed to be secured with an American export guarantee. But that does not work out.
And so the Russian Prosecutor General’s Office suggests doing the deal through Germany – with Hewlett-Packard ISE GmbH in the Bavarian town of Dornach. Now it all goes quickly: in February 2003 the Russian authorities approve the deal, in November the German HP subsidiary applies for a loan from Dresdner Bank, in March 2004 the German Ministry of Economics and Labor gives the deal its blessing, and then the German HP subsidiary receives an export guarantee from Euler Hermes. That means that HP shifts its risk in the deal to the German taxpayer.
At this point, the bribes have already been arranged – they are hidden in the documents which both the Economics Ministry and auditors at Euler Hermes reviewed. But the German authorities do a sloppy job. They do not apply the same scrutiny as tax officials in the State of Saxony would later apply. Accordingly, the bribery deal receives an official German blessing. A spokeswoman of the Economy Ministry says the ministry can not comment on specific transactions due to business confidentiality. But the ministry says that in principle the German government would be released from its liability if a transaction should be concluded with the help of corruption. Euler Hermes did not offer any further comment.
Around 7.6 million Euros, one fifth of the entire sum, is designated as dirty money from the outset. This was promised by the HP representative in Russia – the German Hilmar L.
Hilmar L., who is now 63 years old, is well versed in dubious agreements. He is an astrophysicist who studied in the Soviet Union and later worked at the Central Institute for Astrophysics in Babelsberg. But he is also an informant for the Stasi, the East German secret police. Between 1980 and 1990, he goes to great efforts to spy on his colleagues.
He handles the political changes in Germany well and starts a career in IT in the early 1990s. In 1996, he becomes a manager for HP in Russia. At a business inauguration in 1999, Hilmar L. meets President Putin. Did he approach Putin as a „colleague“? Or did Putin, whose spy service has access to countless Stasi documents, know about Hilmar L.’s former double life? Might this be why HP was awarded the crooked deal?
We do not know. Only one thing is for sure: according to German investigators, HP did not make the cheapest offer. Yet it still received the contract to provide the Russian Prosecutor General’s Office with a computer network.
Money laundering via display cabinets
At this point, Sergej B. comes into the picture – the Russian computer dealer who is friends with the Saxon Christian Democrat Ralf K. Somebody has to move the dirty money from HP to the corrupt Russian officials. An HP employee suggested Sergej B., now he gets to work with Ralf K., according to prosecutors. In early 2004 they filled up the slush fund, then they start distributing the money.
Around 2.6 million Euros go to the London-based company Verwood Industries Limited – with no services rendered in return. Prosecutors allege that Ralf K. transfers around 310,000 Euros to Bracefield Builders Limited in the UK – also with no services rendered. A mysterious Marple Associated S.A. in Belize receives 632,000 Euros – again with no services rendered. And so on. Via ever more dummy firms in various tax havens, the money finally reaches the Russian apparatchiks.
Sergej B. also keeps the Russian intelligence service FSB in mind. Around 550,000 Euros go to an account in the Republic of Srbska. It belongs to a the Kotrax Group, and the transfer takes place without any type of contract. There is not even an effort to pretend that services were rendered, as in the other cases. German authorities assume that Kotrax is a front for the FSB. According to credit card statements, the money was used to live it up. There are statements for luxury watches and swimming pool equipment, along with a bill from the Hotel Palace Berlin for 108,000 Euros, paid for by the Kotrax Group. The „Presidential Suite“ there costs 1800 Euros per night. In a statement, a hotel representative said that the hotel was not aware of these events, and that she did not have information about such a bill.
The way he presents himself, Sergej B. is an exemplary internet entrepreneur with a charitable heart. By his own account, his companies have 5000 employees. Sergej B. immediately comes to mind in discussions on e-government in Russia. His employees are tasked with digitalizing files from ministries, libraries, company archives and numerous other data collections.
What Russia’s public does not know: Sergej B. leads a double life. He not only moves around dirty money for the FSB. The German case files also reveal that he himself is an FSB agent.
This puts his engagement in digitalizing data collections in a completely new light. A secret agent with access to seemingly every file in Russia? It is the dream of any spy.
It gets even better. When all is done and dusted and every corrupt bill has been paid, there is still money left over – around 1 million Euros are left in the slush fund. Sergej B. directs his good friend Ralf K. to order display cabinets and safety glass – for renovating the Zarizyno Museum which is being restored by the city of Moscow.
Ralf K. does as told, according to the investigation by Dresden prosecutors. He transfers 945,371 Euros to the company Knauf/Kassel in Fuldabrück for display cabinets and 106,850 to the company Hanseata in Wentdorf for safety glas. Both companies deliver the goods to Moscow in 2007.
But when asked today, the Moscow office of the leading architect who chose the display cabinets says they were financed by the city.
We could not reconstruct this flow of money. But it reeks of money laundering. The display cabinets were verifiably bought with money from Ralf K.’s slush fund. Did the „clean“ money from the city of Moscow then go to Sergej B.? And if it did, where did it go from there?
Another oddity is that Sergej B., who usually enjoys speaking publicly about his business deals, does not mention the display cabinets on his website. There we only find the statement this his company digitalized the archives of the Zarizyno library. Display cabinets are not mentioned. Sergej B. declined to comment when asked by CORRECTIV. The museum and the city of Moscow did not answer questions.
State collapse under Putin
The legend continues: under President Boris Yeltsin, Russia was corrupt. Then Vladimir Putin came in and cleaned everything up. But in fact, at least the separation of powers was in part still upheld under Yeltsin. Only under Putin was the political system brought into line. Fraud became institutionalized.
A central pillar of Putin’s power is the cooperation between the Prosecutor General’s Office and the intelligence service. Members of the intelligence service do the dirty work; then the state attorneys ensure the intelligence officials do not have to account for their actions.
Such as when the true perpetrators of the apartment bombings were covered up, leading to the Second Chechen War in 1999.
Such as in the giant corruption scandal surrounding the furniture store „Tri Kita“ (Three Whales), and where investigators paid for their curiosity with their lives.
Such as in the countless raids against Russian business people where greedy officials throw innocent citizens into jail so they could confiscate their assets. In 2011, around 400,000 Russian business people were in jail unjustly – this is one of the reasons why Russia’s economy is suffering.
Again and again, we come across the Ustinov/Biryukov tandem, the two heads of the Prosecutor General’s Office.
Ustinov stops the investigation of the ominous „sugar sack carriers“. Biryukov hampers the investigation into the corruption scandal surrounding the furniture store „Three Whales“. Ustinov pushes through the law on „Confiscating Assets“, a carte blanche for the raids against business people. In the investigations of oligarchs, in the scandal surrounding the sinking of the submarine „Kursk“ – again and again, the two heads of the Prosecutor General’s Office save Putin’s skin.
And at the very beginning of this cooperation stands the loan to the Prosecutor General’s Office which Vladimir Putin approved. As if Putin wanted to reward these men for their loyalty.
When will justice be administered?
We asked the Russian data collector Sergej B., the former and present-day Russian President Vladimir Putin, the present-day senator Yuri Biryukov, the former Prosecutor General Ustinov, and the former head of the FSB Patruchev, the former head of Hewlett-Packard in Russia Hilmar L. to comment on these allegations.
They all prefer to remain silent. If they do make a statement at a later time – we will update this story.
Ralf K., the former district assemblyman for the Christian Democrats, whose business was used to implement the HP transaction according to prosecutors in Dresden, also declined to answer questions.
According to German prosecutors, the Russian officials who were involved in the HP deal committed criminal offenses. The main culprit they identify is the man with the rasping voice, Yuri Biryukov. The case is known in Russia because the German authorities have requested legal assistance. But so far, none of the Russian suspects have faced investigation in Russia.
For Hewlett-Packard, the bribery deal was immensely profitable: it helped HP gain a kind of monopoly position in the Russian market. According to the business plan „Troika“, HP’s turnover in Russia was supposed to rise from 700 in 2003 million to 2 billion Dollars in 2007 – with a profit margin of 42 percent. It appears that a 7.6 million Euro bribe brought HP billions in profits.
According to a criminal investigator, this was HP’s „golden ticket“ to the Russian market.
HP declined to comment when CORRECTIV confronted the company with the accusations. Patrik Edlund, spokesman of HP Germany, declined comment citing ongoing legal proceedings in Germany. He enclosed, however, a press release from 2014, in which the company said that the number of employees concerned was small and that they were no longer with the company.
The American judiciary has already taken action. In 2014, a US court sentenced Hewlett-Packard to a fine of 108 million Dollars due to corruption and bribery payments in Russia, Poland and Mexico – whereby the Russian deal was particularly serious.
Oddly enough, the US case is not directed against the company’s management. At the time, this included a woman with significant political connections: Carly Fiorina, who is now a presidential candidate in the US Republican Party primaries. In her candidacy announcement, she underlined her success in running the computer company. What did Carly Fiorina know of the bribery payments in Russia under her leadership? She declined comment when approached by CORRECTIV.
The US judges drew on the German indictment which was initially filed in the District Court in Leipzig in 2012. After almost three years of examination, and without making a decision on whether to set a trial date, the District Court recently handed the files over to the Leipzig State Court. Now the State-Court judges have to decide on whether or not to accept the indictment. Only then will the decision be made on whether to set a trial date. But there are indications that the judges at the Leipzig State Court are now taking the case very seriously.
This delay is surprising. Because the German state has invested millions of Euros in investigating the case. And it could bring in immense fines should the German court reach a conviction. Public prosecutors in Dresden have petitioned the court to have the profits from Hewlett-Packard’s subsequent business dealings in Russia confiscated if the company is found to have benefited from corruption. This is possible in legal terms: following the Cologne waste scandal, the German Federal Court of Justice ruled in 2005 that in cases of corruption, not only the deal where bribery was involved is relevant. Profits from all subsequent dealings can also be taken into account.
As stated: HP made billions in profits in Russia.
That means a conviction could lead to hundreds of millions of Euros in seized profits. To be paid, among others, to the German State of Saxony.
Putin week at CORRECTIV
German-English Translation: Noah Walker-Crawford
Illustration/Animation (Article): Nick Böse, Simon Jockers
Copy Editor: Ariel Hauptmeier
Collaboration: Daniel Drepper, Frederik Richter, Jonathan Sachse, Julia Brötz, Stefan Wehrmeyer
In Cooperation with RTL and Mediapart.
CORRECTIV ist spendenfinanziert!
CORRECTIV ist das erste gemeinnützige Recherchezentrum im deutschsprachigen Raum. Unser Ziel ist eine aufgeklärte Gesellschaft. Denn nur gut informierte Bürgerinnen und Bürger können auf demokratischem Weg Probleme lösen und Verbesserungen herbeiführen. Mit Ihrer Spende ermöglichen Sie unsere Arbeit. Jetzt unterstützen!
The System of Putin
One of the prime suspects in the HP corruption scandal knows how to keep silent